A lender asks for “CPA financial statements.” You already have a balance sheet and profit-and-loss report, so it sounds like a simple request. Before ordering a report, ask the lender to clarify exactly what it will accept.
A financial statement review and a compilation are different engagements. Choosing the appropriate one starts with the recipient’s written requirements, your reporting deadline and the condition of your accounting records.
What is the difference between a review and a compilation?
In a compilation, a CPA applies accounting and financial-reporting expertise to assist management in presenting financial statements. A compilation provides no assurance. The accountant does not have to be independent, but a lack of independence must be disclosed in the compilation report.
A review provides limited assurance. An independent CPA performs inquiries and analytical procedures and considers whether material changes are needed for the statements to follow the applicable reporting framework. A review is substantially narrower than an audit and does not provide an audit opinion.
The AICPA’s comparison of compilations, reviews and audits explains these distinctions. The right choice is the engagement that meets the intended user’s needs.
Five questions to ask before hiring a CPA
Which report is required? Ask whether the lender needs a compilation, review or audit. “CPA-prepared” alone leaves room for misunderstanding.
Which reporting framework is acceptable? Confirm whether the lender requires U.S. GAAP or accepts another appropriate basis of accounting.
Which periods are needed? A request may cover a completed year, comparative years or interim results. Get the period-end dates in writing.
What accompanying information is required? Ask about notes, debt schedules, ownership information or other supporting schedules.
When must the package arrive? Share the deadline before agreeing on the scope. Accounting cleanup can affect the timetable.
What should you send to the CPA?
Begin with the lender’s request, prior financial statements and the most recent trial balance or accounting reports. Prepare bank reconciliations, loan statements, accounts receivable and payable details, and records of significant purchases or unusual transactions. The CPA will provide a request list tailored to the engagement.
If the records are incomplete, say so early. A realistic plan can separate the work needed to bring the books up to date from the work needed for the compilation or review.
Will a compilation always satisfy a small-business lender?
No. The lender decides what it accepts for the particular request. Do not assume a compilation will be sufficient because the business or loan is small, or order a review without confirming that it addresses the requirement.
Does a review guarantee financing or detect every error?
No. A review provides limited assurance about the financial statements; it does not guarantee a loan, bonding approval or discovery of every error. Lending and underwriting decisions remain with the recipient.
Financial statement support for California businesses
Prep Tax Smart provides financial statement reviews and compilations throughout California from our Redding office. Send us the requester’s written requirements and your target delivery date so we can discuss the appropriate engagement, records and scope.
Contact Prep Tax Smart about your financial statement request.